When Ravi bought his first life insurance policy at 28, he told his friends he was investing in his future. Years later, when the policy matured, he discovered the returns were far below what a simple index fund could have delivered. Like many people, Ravi had blurred the line between insurance and investment—and paid for it in lost growth and locked-up money.
This confusion is common. Brochures highlight maturity values, loyalty additions and guaranteed payouts, while the real job of insurance remains in the background. Insurance is a hedge against uncertainty, not a profit engine. It is the seatbelt you wear every day and forget about—until the moment it saves your life.
In this post, we will unpack why insurance should be treated as protection and not investment, how popular policies compare in real numbers, and a simple framework to combine term cover with market-linked investments. The goal is clarity. Once you see insurance as a safety net—and your investments as the trampoline beneath—you can protect your family and still let your wealth compound.
Think of it this way: a fire extinguisher does not “earn” you anything, but it prevents catastrophic loss. That is the role of insurance. If you want growth, you plant seeds and nurture them—your SIPs, ETFs and diversified portfolios. Keep the tools in their proper place and your financial house becomes both safer and stronger.
Insurance as a Hedge Against Uncertainty
Imagine driving without a seatbelt. Most days, you reach home safely and forget the strap ever existed. But in a crash, the seatbelt is the difference between a scare and a catastrophe. Insurance works the same way. You don’t “profit” from wearing a seatbelt, just as you don’t “profit” from having insurance. Instead, it shields you and your family from financial disaster when life takes an unexpected turn.
Life is full of uncertainties—sudden illness, accidents, or premature death. For households dependent on a single breadwinner, the loss of income can be devastating. That’s where life insurance steps in as a true safety tool.
- Term life insurance provides high coverage at a relatively low cost.
- A 30-year-old non-smoker can often secure ₹1 crore cover for ~₹10,000 a year.
- That’s roughly ₹27 per day—less than a café tea—for peace of mind that your loved ones won’t be financially crippled.
Why Insurance Is Not an Investment
When you hear terms like “endowment,” “money-back plan,” or “whole life,” you’re entering the realm where protection and investment are bundled together. On paper it looks neat: pay premiums, get life cover, and receive money back at maturity. In practice, the math rarely favors you.
The sobering reality:
- Low returns: Endowment and money-back policies typically yield about 4–6% annually, often below inflation.
- High costs: A large chunk of your premium goes to mortality charges, commissions, and administrative expenses.
- Lack of flexibility: Stopping or adjusting contributions usually attracts penalties.
- Poor liquidity: Early exits or surrenders often result in steep losses.
Now compare that with inflation, which historically hovers around 6–7% in India. If your policy grows at ~5% while prices rise at ~6–7%, the money you receive after 20 years has actually lost purchasing power. It may feel “safe,” but it’s quietly shrinking in real terms.
A Simple Comparison
Let’s compare two people with the same budget of ₹50,000 a year. The difference between choosing an endowment plan and separating insurance from investment is striking.
Case A: Endowment Policy
- Premium: ₹50,000/year
- Tenure: 20 years
- Sum assured: ₹10–15 lakh
- Maturity value after 20 years: ~₹15–18 lakh
- Effective Return (IRR): ~5–6%
Case B: Term + Investment
- Term policy premium: ₹10,000/year → Coverage: ₹1 crore
- Balance invested in equity index fund: ₹40,000/year at 12% CAGR
- After 20 years: ~₹30 lakh corpus + ₹1 crore insurance cover
- Effective Return: ~12% + complete protection
Why Policyholders Are Disadvantaged in Endowment Plans
Endowment policies may appear comforting, but they often disadvantage policyholders. Here’s why:
- Higher Outgo, Lower Return: A ₹50,000/year endowment policy might give only ₹10–15 lakh cover, whereas a ₹10,000/year term plan can provide ₹1 crore cover.
- Lack of Transparency: Policy brochures highlight “guaranteed maturity values” but rarely clarify the internal rate of return (IRR), which is typically dismal.
- Opportunity Cost: By locking money into low-yield endowment plans, you miss out on the superior long-term growth of equities, bonds, or ETFs. Over 20–25 years, this gap can easily run into tens of lakhs of rupees.
Endowment vs. Term + Investment
Endowment Policy
- Premium: ₹50,000/year
- Tenure: 20 years
- Sum assured: ₹10–15 lakh
- Maturity value: ~₹15–18 lakh
- IRR: ~5–6%
- Low coverage, poor returns
Term + Investment
- Term policy premium: ₹10,000/year → Coverage ₹1 crore
- Invest balance ₹40,000/year in index fund (12% CAGR)
- Corpus after 20 years: ~₹30 lakh
- Insurance cover: ₹1 crore
- IRR: ~12% + Full Protection
- High coverage, strong returns
Endowment = Safety illusion with low growth | Term + Investment = Protection + Wealth Creation
Analogies to Clarify the Concept
If this still feels abstract, here are some everyday analogies to keep it simple:
- Seatbelt in a car: It won’t make you richer, but it can save your life in a crash.
- Fire extinguisher at home: You hope never to use it, but its presence prevents total disaster.
- Safety net in a circus: The trapeze artist doesn’t expect to fall, but the net makes the act survivable.
The Smarter Strategy – Separate Protection from Investment
Financial planners worldwide recommend the simple but powerful formula: “Buy Term and Invest the Rest.”
1. Buy a Term Insurance Policy
- Coverage should equal 10–15 times your annual income.
- Example: If your annual income is ₹10 lakh, aim for coverage of ₹1–1.5 crore.
- Premiums are low and fixed for the policy term.
2. Invest Separately for Wealth Creation
- Use equity mutual funds, ETFs, or bonds for long-term growth.
- SIPs (Systematic Investment Plans) allow disciplined wealth accumulation.
- For a moderate-risk investor, equity funds can deliver 10–12% CAGR over 15–20 years.
3. Enjoy Flexibility
- If you need liquidity, you can redeem investments without affecting your insurance cover.
- If markets perform well, your wealth grows; if not, your family is still protected by insurance.
Common Counterarguments — And the Reality
“But endowment policies are safe and guaranteed.”
Yes, they are “safe,” but so is a fixed deposit — and both deliver similarly poor returns. The guarantee often hides the reality of wealth erosion due to inflation.
“At least I’m forced to save with an endowment.”
True, but forced saving is a weak reason to accept subpar returns. Disciplined investing through SIPs achieves the same outcome without locking you into an inferior product.
“My agent told me I’ll get good bonuses.”
Bonuses are not real profits; they’re marketing terms. Even with bonuses, the IRR for most policies still struggles to cross 6%.
Learning the Hard Way
A close friend once surrendered his money-back policy after diligently paying premiums for 8 years. The surrender value he received was barely 40% of what he had paid in. He described it wryly as “buying the most expensive fire extinguisher of my life.”
Disappointed, he switched to a simple term plan and began a SIP in index funds. Within just 5 years, his investment returns had already surpassed the 8-year maturity projection of his old policy. The lesson was unmistakable: use insurance purely for protection, and let investments take care of growth.
Conclusion – Think Protection, Not Profit
Insurance is like a safety shield. You don’t buy it to get rich. You buy it so that your family’s dreams—education, home, and financial security—don’t collapse if something happens to you.
Endowment and money-back plans blur the lines and often disadvantage policyholders. The smarter, clearer strategy is simple:
- Use term insurance to protect against life’s uncertainties.
- Use investments (mutual funds, ETFs, stocks, bonds) to create wealth.
Frequently Asked Questions
What if I outlive my term insurance?
That’s the expected outcome. Term insurance is a safety net for a low-probability, high-impact event. If you outlive the term, your family enjoyed protection while your investments (SIPs, ETFs, bonds) did the wealth building. You don’t need a payout for term insurance to be successful—its purpose is protection.
How much life cover do I really need?
Start with 10–15× annual income, add liabilities (home/car loan), and include 3–5 years of key goals (education, living expenses). Subtract liquid assets already set aside. Round up to the next ₹50 lakh or ₹1 crore for simplicity.
How long should the term be?
Choose a term that covers you until you reach financial independence or your major obligations end—typically age 60–65. If you expect to retire early and be debt-free by 55, a shorter term may be sufficient.
Are “return of premium” (TROP) term plans worth it?
Usually not. They increase premiums significantly and the “returned premiums” imply a very low effective return. If you want money back, invest the premium difference in a low-cost index fund and keep pure term for protection.
Should I buy riders like accidental death or critical illness?
Accidental death riders are optional; your primary risk is mortality from any cause, already covered by term. A separate, well-priced standalone critical illness or disability cover can be useful because these risks affect income during life. Compare costs and coverage carefully.
ULIPs vs. mutual funds + term insurance—what’s better?
ULIPs bundle investing with insurance, often with higher costs and a 5-year lock-in. A combination of term insurance and low-cost mutual funds/ETFs is usually more transparent, flexible, and cost-efficient over long horizons.
Endowment policies claim bonuses—doesn’t that improve returns?
Even after adding bonuses, many endowment/money-back policies deliver ~4–6% IRR over long periods—often below inflation. The opportunity cost versus market-linked investments is substantial.
How do I check the true return (IRR) of my existing policy?
List all premiums (dates and amounts) as cash outflows and all benefits/maturity values as inflows. Use an IRR/XIRR function (in Excel/Google Sheets) on the dated cash flows. Compare the result with long-run inflation and with what a disciplined SIP might have achieved.
What about term insurance for homemakers or non-earning spouses?
Coverage is still valuable because their role has economic value (childcare, household management). Many insurers allow coverage based on the earning spouse’s income. Confirm eligibility and limits with the insurer.
What documents should my nominee have for a smooth claim?
Keep the policy document, premium receipts, ID/address proofs, death certificate (in claim events), hospital records if applicable, and the insurer’s claim form in a clearly labeled folder. Share the insurer’s helpline and the policy number with your nominee.
Does term insurance have tax benefits?
Tax rules change over time. There may be deductions on premiums and tax treatment on benefits subject to prevailing laws. Check the latest guidance or consult a qualified tax professional before relying on any specific provision.
When should I review or increase my cover?
Review after major life events: marriage, birth of a child, taking a home loan, or a significant income jump. It’s better to adjust coverage proactively than to discover a shortfall during an emergency.
More on Financial Freedom
- Financial Literacy for the Digital Age: Essential Skills for Managing Money Online
- Why Doing Less Can Earn You More: A Wealth Strategy That Works
- Top 15 Proven Side Hustles with Low Entry Barriers to Boost Your Income
- Mastering Stock Screeners: How to Find Winning Stocks Like a Pro
- Market Corrections: The Smart Investor’s Gateway to Bargain Deals
- Dividends vs. Growth Stocks: Which Investment Strategy Suits You?
- Stocks vs. Real Estate: Which One Builds Wealth Faster?
- The Most Common Money Mistakes People Make and How to Avoid Them
No comments:
Post a Comment